Candidate Information

2023 ELECTION:  SURVEY RESPONSES

FROM LOCAL CITY CANDIDATES

Below, look for info on YOUR CITY CANDIDATES by scrolling through the alphabetized list of cities.  (Candidates are listed alphabetically by FIRST name, beneath each city heading).  But first,  …some background info on the survey sent out by “Southern Utahns For Transparency”:

SURVEY DETAILS:

Before the 6/7/23 filing deadline, over one-hundred candidates applied to run for municipal office in various cities within Washington County.  An eight-question survey was emailed to each of these candidates in mid-June and again in mid-July (see Survey Intro & Questions below).  They were asked to reply within a week, and if they didn’t respond, they each received a follow-up text.  After these three contacts, those who failed to respond received a telephone call on July 27th or 28th, again using the contact information they provided on their candidacy declaration form on file with their city. 

At bottom are the verbatim answers that were received (including any misspellings), listed in alphabetical order, first by city, and then by first name.  The majority of the candidates did not respond, despite the fact that multiple requests were made for two months (as noted above). All responses received from June 12th to August 12th  are included here.

SURVEY RECOMMENDATIONS:

In races with more than one candidate, we highly recommend you vet the best candidates, namely, those who signed the petition AND provided good responses to all 8 survey questions.  Conversely, we do not recommend candidates who:  (1) failed to sign the petition, or (2) answered the survey questions poorly, or (3) skirted around the questions to avoid a direct answer, or (4) failed to answer all 8 questions, or (5) completely ignored all questions and did not respond to their constituents at all.  We’ve provided the phone numbers listed on their filing applications, so go ahead and try calling these candidates for some private answers, but it’s unacceptable for a candidate to be unwilling to publicly take a stand. 

Best wishes in your vetting!

SURVEY INTRO:

“…As you probably know, city council members and mayors serve as the Board of Canvassers every two years, where they each personally certify whether city elections are accurate or not.  This has now become a critical responsibility, given the crisis we currently face: 62% of American voters have lost confidence in our elections (see 5/2023 and 8/2022 Rasmussen Polls).  Sadly, in Southern Utah, lack of trust exceeds 70%.  Securing our elections and restoring public trust is of paramount importance, but our state legislature still hasn’t taken meaningful action, so we must start from the bottom-up. What can be done at the city level?

For over twenty years, countless cyber and national security experts (on both the Left and the Right) have warned that America’s electronic election systems are vulnerable to outside interference:  we would challenge you to find even one qualified expert testifying otherwise.  One important solution is hand-counted elections, which were successfully done in America for over two centuries. Entire nations across Europe, plus Canada, Israel, etc, have switched back to hand-counting, with dozens of American cities & counties recently making the switch as well.  Utah law already allows for this, and we’re promoting candidates who support a return to transparency—especially in our elections. 

Will you please complete our survey and let us know where you stand?  If you have any questions, please let us know.  And please reply to this email within a week, so that answers can be posted on our bi-partisan website.  Again, thanks for running for office!  We truly appreciate all those willing to serve in Southern Utah!   Sincerely,  www.SouthernUtahnsForTransparency.com”

SURVEY QUESTIONS:

1) To eliminate current vulnerabilities to software errors or digital manipulation, do you support a return to hand-counted elections in our city & county?  What steps will you take to implement hand-counting in city elections (either during tabulation, or during canvassing)?

2) In city elections, what steps will you take as a check against ballot-stuffing, which is a separate vulnerability in our elections? (Cast Vote Record Analysis? Actual canvassing of voter rolls?  Other?)

3) In city council meetings, will you support a public comment policy that aligns with all our fellow Class 1&2 Counties in Utah, each of which allow open public comment without signup, before any voting, including at least three minutes each for unlimited persons?

4) Are you in support of a clear city website with one grid that includes links to all city council minutes, recordings, and agendas with detailed links to all items listed so the public is informed about items to be voted on at least one week in advance?

5) What other steps will you implement to make city government more transparent, accessible, and answerable to the public?

6) Do you support current budgets, taxes, & spending in our city, and if not, what would you change?

7) *Most important of all:  As a constituent, or as an elected representative, what actions have you already personally taken in support of items #1-6 above?

8) Over 1,000 Southern Utahns have signed our online petition so far:  have you?  If not, will you sign it now? Go to:  https://www.southernutahnsfortransparency.com/petition

SURVEY RESPONSES:

APPLE VALLEY MAYOR

--Vote for 1 (Sept. 5 Primary Election; Nov. 21 General Election)

--In Apple Valley, no mayoral candidates have replied to the survey or signed the petition yet

Michael Lee Farrar, 951-897-6706

Did not reply to survey once contact was made, and has not signed petition

Landon Holm, 435-690-0188

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Walter Earl Josey, 435-817-1599

Has not yet completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, and 1 phone call, across two months)

--Withdrawn from race:  Marty Lisonbee & Michael Barrett

APPLE VALLEY COUNCIL

--Vote for up to 2 (Sept. 5 Primary Election; Nov. 21 General Election)

--Four Apple Valley Council candidates have signed the petition:  Barratt Nielson, David Lane, Janet Prentice, and Raymond Jessop

Barratt Eric Nielson, 435-375-9270

Has not replied to survey (after 2 emails, text, and 1 phone call); HAS signed petition

David Lane, 435-313-0357

Has not replied to survey (after 2 emails, text, and 1 phone call); HAS signed petition

Janet Prentice, 877-1002

Has not replied to survey (after 2 emails, text, and 1 phone call); HAS signed petition

Margaret Ososki, 702-256-6060

Has not replied to survey (after 2 emails, text, and 1 attempted phone call, across two months) and has not signed petition.  Mailbox full.

Raymond Lester Jessop, 435-817-1452

Has not replied to survey (after 2 emails, text, and 1 phone call); HAS signed petition

--Withdrawn from race:  Donald Parr, Stewart Riding, Becky Wood, Jarry Zaharias

ENTERPRISE COUNCIL

No Enterprise candidate has replied to the survey or signed the petition yet

Bill Fowler:  435-862-9793

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Delbert Staheli:  435-632-4147

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Jared Bollinger:  435-231-1941

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Leann Nebeker:  435-695-7051

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months).

Number not in service.

Mikehel Murphy:  801-652-7210

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Roy Adams:  435-878-2196

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Yvonne Colby:  435-231-1738

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

HILDALE COUNCIL

No Hildale candidate has replied to the survey or signed the petition yet

Darlene Stubbs:  435-669-3371

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Derick Holm:  701-580-2183

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Jared Nicol:  801-864-3768

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 attempted phone call, across two months)

Restricted number.

JVar Dutson:  435-705-0835

He hung up on caller.  Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Lawrence Barlow:  435-619-7393

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 attempted phone call, across two months)

Number not accepting calls.

Luke Meredith:  623-396-2454

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

HURRICANE COUNCIL

--On Sept. 5th Primary and Nov. 21st General Election, vote for up to 3 (but if there are only 1 or 2 good candidates, then it’s usually best to only vote for 1 or 2)

--No Hurricane candidate has signed the petition yet

Amy Werrett:  435-313-3792  (has not signed petition)

1. To eliminate current vulnerabilities to software errors or digital manipulation, do you support a return to hand-counted elections in our city & county?  What steps will you take to implement hand-counting in city elections (either during tabulation, or during canvassing)?

            I do not support a return to hand counting as the first step.  I support having elections where citizens can trust the results.   Hand counting is not 100% foolproof and subject to errors and manipulation as well, and has a similar, if not worse, error rate to machine counting. Mistakes, fraud, error, and manipulation can be made equally with hand counting.   I think it is more important to clean up voter rolls after every election cycle and make sure we are counting accurate votes, and conduct audits as required by state law with close elections. I do support auditing votes as needed.  I support voter identification.  I support reasonable measures to verify voters and hold elections that we can trust. 

[Editor’s Note]:  For studies on hand-count accuracy go to   Hand Count — Southern Utahns for Transparency

2.      In city elections, what steps will you take as a check against ballot-stuffing, which is a separate vulnerability in our elections? (Cast Vote Record Analysis? Actual canvassing of voter rolls? 

            I support having an in person polling place for those who like to vote in person, with mail in ballots available liberally as well.  I have voted successfully by mail and think we get better participation with both in person and mail in balloting options. I do think the county needs to do a better job of updating voter rolls.  

3.      In city council meetings, will you support a public comment policy that aligns with all our fellow Class 1&2 Counties in Utah, each of which allow open public comment without signup, before any voting, including at least three minutes each for unlimited persons?

            Meetings need to be conducted in an orderly fashion with efficacy and accountability of taxpayers. I would be willing to look at options which allow citizens to feel heard and participate efficiently without lengthening meetings unnecessarily. Hearing repetitive comments over and over at a meeting isn't an effective way to run a meeting.   Hearing multiple viewpoints is important.  

4.      Are you in support of a clear city website with one grid that includes links to all city council minutes, recordings, and agendas with detailed links to all items listed so the public is informed about items to be voted on at least one week in advance? 

            I think this is a great idea.  

5.      What other steps will you implement to make city government more transparent, accessible, and answerable to the public? 

I think the city can do a much better job with posting on social media, and sending out city wide emails and text messages.  As a city council member, I would want to keep citizens informed on city council issues. I would use Facebook, Instagram, email and other avenues to keep citizens informed.  As a precinct leader and delegate, I used our precinct facebook page, and email to update my precinct with current events and issues.  My precinct would tell you I tried diligently to vet candidates and seek input from them.  My profession as a speech/language pathologist makes me an expert in communication.  Part of communication is being an effective listener to understand concerns and follow up.  My job also qualifies me to be an expert communicator and advocate for the needs of the citizens of Hurricane.  

I also live in the west part of Hurricane and see the growth and challenges we face to make sure all parts of Hurricane feel included and part of this great community. 

6.   Do you support current budgets, taxes, & spending in our city, and if not, what would you change?

I believe in a fiscally conservative city government with a charge to implement wise policies that plan for future growth responsibly, balanced with safeguarding personal freedoms.   

7.      *Most important of all:  As a constituent, or as an elected representative, what actions have you already personally taken in support of items #1-6 above?

            [no answer]

8.      Over 1,000 Southern Utahns have signed our online petition so far:  have you?  If not, will you sign it now? Go to:  https://www.southernutahnsfortransparency.com/petition

            [has not signed petition]

Clark Fawcett:  435-668-5617

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

David Sanders, incumbent:  435-703-4789

Has not yet completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Verbally expressed the opinion that he will not take a side and has not signed petition.

Drew Ellerman:  435-632-2989

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Joseph Prete, incumbent:  joseph.prete@gmail.com

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months).  No phone number listed on campaign filing application.

Lucille Douroux:  801-403-7242    (has not signed petition)

1) To eliminate current vulnerabilities to software errors or digital manipulation, do you support a return to hand-counted elections in our city & county?  What steps will you take to implement hand-counting in city elections (either during tabulation, or during canvassing)?

I looked up a KSL investigation. Findings: few cases reported and few cases prosecuted. “In Utah, there hasn’t been anything that anyone has showed us that supports actual voter fraud.” “From 2002 to 2022, there have only been 17 cases that have been prosecuted.”  For me to 100% support change I will need to know the cost associated with returning back to paper ballots , accuracy (I remember the Florida paper ballot loose Chad issue) of paper ballots, and would like to know how those working and attending college, working multiple jobs, view of the elderly, and those with transportation issues and their ability to vote. I am aware of the mayors husband losing by just eight votes, and a case on the East Coast where a member won by just one vote. I’m a strong proponent of every vote counts and  truly matters. I’m also a staunch proponent of recounts in cases deemed necessary.

           [Editor’s Note:  the question was about our vulnerabilities to fraud]

2) In city elections, what steps will you take as a check against ballot-stuffing, which is a separate vulnerability in our elections? (Cast Vote Record Analysis? Actual canvassing of voter rolls?  Other?)

I’ve been researching for years the general election and voter fraud. Believe it or not findings are so far and few between, a number of cases proved to be person who voted and died soon after , another allegation of mass voter fraud turned out to be Nevada military personnel stations in California, who voted in California, their votes were thrown out and had to be reinstated.  My father, uncles, brother, and nephews, cousins, have also been a military, and why I’m so strongly for their equal voters rights, and no manipulation at the voter system

           [Editor’s Note:  the question was about our vulnerabilities to fraud]

3) In city council meetings, will you support a public comment policy that aligns with all our fellow Class 1&2 Counties in Utah, each of which allow open public comment without signup, before any voting, including at least three minutes each for unlimited persons?

            100%  --Primary reason why I’m running to representation of the people for the people. I will only be strong city Council member if I have the people behind me as a whole.

4) Are you in support of a clear city website with one grid that includes links to all city council minutes, recordings, and agendas with detailed links to all items listed so the public is informed about items to be voted on at least one week in advance?

             100% in agreement. Another reason why I’m running for city council.

5) What other steps will you implement to make city government more transparent, accessible, and answerable to the public?

I’m funny my own campaign, because I do not want to be in the pocket of anyone but my constituents. I plan on being transparent, and I plan on having a website to seek input from citizens, like myself, on the utilization of our tax dollars. I plan on being an ambassador for us citizens. 

6) Do you support current budgets, taxes, & spending in our city, and if not, what would you change?

            I ran an international logistics, traffic department with the constraints of a budget, and I would do the same for the city Council position. Rest assured, I want my tax tax dollars to get the most bang for the buck.

7) *Most important of all:  As a constituent, or as an elected representative, what actions have you already personally taken in support of items #1-6 above?

           ---

8) Over 1,000 Southern Utahns have signed our online petition so far:  have you?  If not, will you sign it now? Go to:  https://www.southernutahnsfortransparency.com/petition

            [has not signed petition]

I’m an honest individual and I know this position is going to bring a lot of work hours and headaches, I’m up for the challenge. Wearing multiple hat is no new task for me. My four years an office will consist of transparency, honesty, and integrity. I know I’m not going to see is all the people all the time but why did you have to bring to the city council seat is compromise. We needed in town be met. 

I’ll have to further look into your last question. As for transparency, I can 100% tell you, since becoming a city council candidate, some folks are not having any issues gathering information about me. I’m thinking others know more about me than I know about me  

I have signs with access to my about me page, I have more information listed on the city campaign page, and will be providing even more information on the county /state website. No one is harder on me than I am on myself. If you have the secret to making everyone happy please do share. 

My intent is to represent all Hurricane taxpayers, not some. Goal is unity in the community for the betterment of coexisting, work, live, shop, and visit. 

Luckily, the position of city council is non partisan so the focus can be entirely related to Hurricane city. Maybe we can be an example to others, especially federal agencies. 

Please know, not everyone has honest intentions, I had to block someone that I was getting unprofessionally too personal. 

Stephen Lemmon:  435-635-2060

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Teri Humphries:  435-773-7631

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Travis Christiansen:  435-229-3213   (has not signed petition)

1.      To eliminate current vulnerabilities to software errors or digital manipulation, do you support a return to hand-counted elections in our city & county?  What steps will you take to implement hand-counting in city elections (either during tabulation, or during canvassing)? 

I do not support a hand count.  I have seen too many errors that way.  I support machine count where we know the coding and which are not connected to the internet

                [Editor’s Note]:  For studies on hand-count accuracy go to   Hand Count — Southern Utahns for Transparency

2.      In city elections, what steps will you take as a check against ballot-stuffing, which is a separate vulnerability in our elections? (Cast Vote Record Analysis? Actual canvassing of voter rolls?  Other?)

I think we do need to turn in ballots on election day.  I do not support the extended early and mail in ballot for all.  Mail me my ballot, but let me turn in it personally.

3.      In city council meetings, will you support a public comment policy that aligns with all our fellow Class 1&2 Counties in Utah, each of which allow open public comment without signup, before any voting, including at least three minutes each for unlimited persons? 

I support public comment so long as the meeting times are kept within decent parameters.  I do not think out meetings should run beyond 10 pm or so.

4.      Are you in support of a clear city website with one grid that includes links to all city council minutes, recordings, and agendas with detailed links to all items listed so the public is informed about items to be voted on at least one week in advance?

Yes. 

5.      What other steps will you implement to make city government more transparent, accessible, and answerable to the public?

I think notice will go a long way.  We should continue to broadcast city council meetings via Zoom, Webex, or other means.

6.      Do you support current budgets, taxes, & spending in our city, and if not, what would you change? 

I think we have not been wasteful, but I am not sure the priorities have always been accurate.

7.      *Most important of all:  As a constituent, or as an elected representative, what actions have you already personally taken in support of items #1-6 above? 

I have participated in my local party caucus and convention system for many years.  I have supported conservative candidates. 

8.      Over 1,000 Southern Utahns have signed our online petition so far:  have you?  If not, will you sign it now? Go to:  https://www.southernutahnsfortransparency.com/petition 

            [has not signed petition]

IVINS COUNCIL

--Sept. 5th Primary and Nov. 21st General Election:  Vote for up to 3 (but if there are only 1 or 2 good candidates, then it’s usually best to only vote for 1 or 2)

--One Ivins candidate has replied to the survey and signed the petition:  James Barden

Cheyne McDonald:  435-656-3844

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

James Barden:  702-824-2538   (has signed petition)

1) To eliminate current vulnerabilities to software errors or digital manipulation, do you support a return to hand-counted elections in our city & county?  What steps will you take to implement hand-counting in city elections (either during tabulation, or during canvassing)?

Yes, I believe we should take a step back and return to hand delivered and counted ballots in all City and County elections. Each voter should provide a valid ID at the polling location, and only 1 ballot per person.  I think all elections should be held in 1 day, 7 am to 7pm.  Electronic ballots are becoming too vulnerable to hacks and this leads to ballot stuffing and cheating.

2) In city elections, what steps will you take as a check against ballot-stuffing, which is a separate vulnerability in our elections? (Cast Vote Record Analysis? Actual canvassing of voter rolls?  Other?)

 See #1

3) In city council meetings, will you support a public comment policy that aligns with all our fellow Class 1&2 Counties in Utah, each of which allow open public comment without signup, before any voting, including at least three minutes each for unlimited persons?

 All City Council & Planning Commission meetings should allow a public comment on every item on the agenda, however the comments should not be allowed to get out of hand, comments should have a limit of 2 minutes per person.

4) Are you in support of a clear city website with one grid that includes links to all city council minutes, recordings, and agendas with detailed links to all items listed so the public is informed about items to be voted on at least one week in advance?

All of the agenda items should be posted on the city website a minimum of 5 days in advance of the meeting, with all information about the agenda items.

5) What other steps will you implement to make city government more transparent, accessible, and answerable to the public?

The City should post on their website all information about any and all public meetings, and notices should be posted in all government and city establishments.  Being as a lot of the residents are employed, I believe the City Hall should be open on Saturday on a limited schedule (8-12).

6) Do you support current budgets, taxes, & spending in our city, and if not, what would you change?

 Less funds should be spent on new pavement and should be spent on keeping current roads in repair and clean.  More funds should be made available for bike paths and walkways (more shade and water fountains).

7) *Most important of all:  As a constituent, or as an elected representative, what actions have you already personally taken in support of items #1-6 above?

           I have made several suggestions at the meetings, a few which have been implemented, such as larger signage on projects to be visible to all residents a minimum of 15 days prior to the beginning of the project.  All elected officials need to begin to be pro-active instead of re-active in their decisions.

8) Over 1,000 Southern Utahns have signed our online petition so far:  have you?  If not, will you sign it now? Go to:  https://www.southernutahnsfortransparency.com/petition

[has signed petition]

Jenny Johnson:  435-668-6751

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Kevin Smith:  435-680-2891

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Paul Bryson:  661-644-5902

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Sharon Barton:  435-922-5912

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Sharon Gillespie:  435-429-5987

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Susan Ertel:  435-229-8819     (has not signed petition)

1.      To eliminate current vulnerabilities to software errors or digital manipulation, do you support a return to hand-counted elections in our city & county?  What steps will you take to implement hand-counting in city elections (either during tabulation, or during canvassing)?

I do not support hand-counted elections. Research shows that machine-counted elections have multiple safeguards in place to ensure accuracy, and if security measures are updated frequently, which they are, machine-counted elections are accurate. Hand-counted elections are fraught with human error. Here is a link to a report from the Brennan Center outlining the source of the misinformation regarding machine-counted elections. https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/hand-counting-votes-proven-bad-idea

 [Editors Note:  this link erroneously references a 2007 Rice Univ. study which was NOT using paper ballots:  the point of the study was to show the errors associated with counting thermal paper spooled vote receipts.  It also fails to state known error rates for machine counts, or compare the much bigger scale of possible error for machines.]

2.      In city elections, what steps will you take as a check against ballot-stuffing, which is a separate vulnerability in our elections? (Cast Vote Record Analysis? Actual canvassing of voter rolls?  Other?)

             Safeguards are in place already in Utah to guarantee that a single ballot comes from a single voter.

3.      In city council meetings, will you support a public comment policy that aligns with all our fellow Class 1&2 Counties in Utah, each of which allow open public comment without signup, before any voting, including at least three minutes each for unlimited persons?

Are you referring to county-wide meetings or local city council meetings? I am attaching the current Council Rules of Procedure which outline the procedure for public comment in section 18.2. I will follow these guidelines issued by the State of Utah  https://www.utah.gov/pmn/files/644557.pdf

[Editors Note:  this link is not State of Utah requirements; it’s only posted on the state website as just a random guideline from a random city, which could be amended by any city council at any time.  This example is apparently from Taylorsville City in 2008 (see 21.1), but even if it belonged to Ivins, city leaders are free to vote to improve it.  This isn’t a state issue.]

4.      Are you in support of a clear city website with one grid that includes links to all city council minutes, recordings, and agendas with detailed links to all items listed so the public is informed about items to be voted on at least one week in advance?

            Again, I will refer you to the Council Rules of Procedure, sections 15.3 and 15.4. https://www.utah.gov/pmn/files/644557.pdf

[Editors Note:  this link is not State of Utah requirements; it’s only posted on the state website as just a random guideline from a random city, which could be amended by any city council at any time.  This example is apparently from Taylorsville City in 2008 (see 21.1), but even if it belonged to Ivins, city leaders are free to vote to improve it.  This isn’t a state issue.]

5.      What other steps will you implement to make city government more transparent, accessible, and answerable to the public?

I believe that the Ivins City Council already operates in a transparent and accessible way. If citizens have questions to be answered, they can approach any city council member to discuss their concerns, and if warranted, those concerns can be brought forward to the entire City Council in a regular meeting.

6.      Do you support current budgets, taxes, & spending in our city, and if not, what would you change?

 I do support the current budget, taxes, and spending in our city.

7.      *Most important of all:  As a constituent, or as an elected representative, what actions have you already personally taken in support of items #1-6 above?

 I want people to be able to vote without fear of intimidation. Voting is a right given to citizens in this country; sadly, many do not exercise that right. I will do my best to get people registered and voting in local elections.

8.      Over 1,000 Southern Utahns have signed our online petition so far:  have you?  If not, will you sign it now? Go to:  https://www.southernutahnsfortransparency.com/petition

            I will not sign this petition. Elections in this country are safe and well regulated.

--Withdrawn from race:  David Robinson

LAVERKIN COUNCIL

--On Sept. 5th Primary and Nov. 21st General Election, vote for up to 3 (but if there are only 1 or 2 good candidates, then it’s usually best to only vote for 1 or 2)

--One LaVerkin candidate has signed the petition: John Valenti

Cody Barnes:  208-390-9164

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Darren Prince:  435-599-3609   (has not signed petition)

1.      To eliminate current vulnerabilities to software errors or digital manipulation, do you support a return to hand-counted elections in our city & county?  What steps will you take to implement hand-counting in city elections (either during tabulation, or during canvassing)?

I like the idea of hand counting, but I don't think it's a realistic option to balloting. I feel there needs to be a happy medium where we are using machines but the votes can be seperated and audited in a timely mannner.

2.      In city elections, what steps will you take as a check against ballot-stuffing, which is a separate vulnerability in our elections? (Cast Vote Record Analysis? Actual canvassing of voter rolls?  Other?)

I think it's important to make sure the voter rolls are accurate and ballots should only be mailed only to those votors who request them and they are verified as registered voters prior to ballots being mailed.

3.      In city council meetings, will you support a public comment policy that aligns with all our fellow Class 1&2 Counties in Utah, each of which allow open public comment without signup, before any voting, including at least three minutes each for unlimited persons?

I support an open public comment without signup policy, but I think there would need to be some type of remedy if a group was trying to filibuster a vote.

4.      Are you in support of a clear city website with one grid that includes links to all city council minutes, recordings, and agendas with detailed links to all items listed so the public is informed about items to be voted on at least one week in advance?

Yes

5.      What other steps will you implement to make city government more transparent, accessible, and answerable to the public?

I feel that city government works for the citizens. They should be the epitomy of customer service and kindness. They should be held accountable to respond to citizens in a timely manner, preferably answering calls whenever possible. 

6.      Do you support current budgets, taxes, & spending in our city, and if not, what would you change?

I think LaVekin does a good job, but I will always look for ways to improve. 

7.      *Most important of all:  As a constituent, or as an elected representative, what actions have you already personally taken in support of items #1-6 above?

As I've prepared for my canidate run I have been contacting current City Council members and County Commissioneers to see what the strengths and weeknesses of La Verkin City. I've also been visiting with many citizens to understand their concerns and what their vision is for the city. 

8.      Over 1,000 Southern Utahns have signed our online petition so far:  have you?  If not, will you sign it now? Go to:  https://www.southernutahnsfortransparency.com/petition

[has not signed petition]

John Valenti:  435-703-5006

Has not replied to survey (after 2 emails, text, and 1 phone call) and HAS signed the petition

Justin Gifford:  435-313-6888

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Micah Gubler:  435-680-1588

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Randy Jaques:  435-669-6038

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Richard Hirschi:  435-632-2243

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

LEEDS COUNCIL

One Leeds candidate has replied to the survey and signed the petition so far:  Jodi McGregor

Jodi McGregor:  435-467-4278   (has signed the petition)

1) To eliminate current vulnerabilities to software errors or digital manipulation, do you support a return to hand-counted elections in our city & county?  What steps will you take to implement hand-counting in city elections (either during tabulation, or during canvassing)?   

We live in a technological age and therefore may not be able to completely get away from computer-driven balloting, but I would suggest that if a software company or product is used then hand counting be done as a secondary verification until which time the public has once again gained trust in this technology. The software and its provider must be thoroughly vetted and transparent. Hand counting only in smaller towns and cities may suffice. Hand counting must be done with policies set in place much like employees in banks handle cash: dual presence (always two people handling the ballots, preferably non-partisan citizens or one each representing both main parties).

2) In city elections, what steps will you take as a check against ballot-stuffing, which is a separate vulnerability in our elections? (Cast Vote Record Analysis? Actual canvassing of voter rolls?  Other?)

  I believe that ballot boxes should only be placed in public areas where cameras are always present to deter ballot stuffing. One suggestion would be in the lobby areas of local post offices. Ballot boxes should also be under lock and key.

3) In city council meetings, will you support a public comment policy that aligns with all our fellow Class 1&2 Counties in Utah, each of which allow open public comment without signup, before any voting, including at least three minutes each for unlimited persons?

     I would support a public comment policy as described in your query, with an enforced three-minute allowance for each citizen but would suggest a hour or two hour time period for these sessions.

4) Are you in support of a clear city website with one grid that includes links to all city council minutes, recordings, and agendas with detailed links to all items listed so the public is informed about items to be voted on at least one week in advance?

     I do support a clear city website with one grid as described in your guery, and would suggest a county or state-wide training program for town and city clerks so that there is uniformity and ease in the site's format. I think this will improve the ability to find capable clerks in each district.

5) What other steps will you implement to make city government more transparent, accessible, and answerable to the public?

I think that in implementing the clear websites there should be a thread where comments and questions from the constituants may be reviewed, approved and then published by the clerks and councilmembers. This will advance transparency and will go far in narrowing down key issues to be discussed at council meetings.

6) Do you support current budgets, taxes, & spending in our city, and if not, what would you change?

I currently am unable to discuss budgets due to the fact that I am not yet privy to budgets vs. current needs in my area. I will have to come back to this one after I've been in office a bit.

7) *Most important of all:  As a constituent, or as an elected representative, what actions have you already personally taken in support of items #1-6 above?

The actions I have taken as an unelected citizen so far is that I read all minutes of past town council meetings so that I am aware of local issues and the key players. I also participate in discussion on our town's unofficial Facebook page where I am able to gauge the "temperature" of my fellow townspeople and deduct where they stand on certain issues.

8) Over 1,000 Southern Utahns have signed our online petition so far:  have you?  If not, will you sign it now? Go to:  https://www.southernutahnsfortransparency.com/petition

I will, indeed, sign the petition and will do so immediately after sending off this reply [has signed petition]

Kohl Furley:  435-619-1819

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

NEW HARMONY

--One New Harmony candidate has replied to the survey and signed the petition so far:  Scott Pace

Marty Larson:  435-592-2733

Not interested in answering survey, and has not signed petition

Scott Pace:  435-701-2376   (has signed the petition)

1) To eliminate current vulnerabilities to software errors or digital manipulation, do you support a return to hand-counted elections in our city & county?  What steps will you take to implement hand-counting in city elections (either during tabulation, or during canvassing)?

            Yes I'd like to see us go back to hand counting paper ballots get out of the ERIC System and do away with mail in ballots. I'm still trying to find out how Washington County changed the voting system Without State Legislators passing a Vote By Mail Bill and being on the General Election Ballot that same year and it was back in 2014 or 2015.

2) In city elections, what steps will you take as a check against ballot-stuffing, which is a separate vulnerability in our elections? (Cast Vote Record Analysis? Actual canvassing of voter rolls?  Other?)

            I believe Actual canvassing would work the best.  On a side note I do recall the Washington County Clerk told me that the reason we went to mail in ballots was they didn't want to drive to the out into the rural mountains towns in a snow storm on election day. That was on the 2014 or 2015 Election Day. Which under the Constitution it states that Only the State Legislature has the right to pass a bill changing Voting Rules and it must be put on the ballot on the General Election That Same Year.

3) In city council meetings, will you support a public comment policy that aligns with all our fellow Class 1&2 Counties in Utah, each of which allow open public comment without signup, before any voting, including at least three minutes each for unlimited persons?

            Yes I do and we do allow for public comment even if there isn't a public hearing.even if it's 2 residents that show up to the meetings.

4) Are you in support of a clear city website with one grid that includes links to all city council minutes, recordings, and agendas with detailed links to all items listed so the public is informed about items to be voted on at least one week in advance?

           Yes

5) What other steps will you implement to make city government more transparent, accessible, and answerable to the public?

            I don't know how we can be more transparent and accessible then we already are living in a small town

6) Do you support current budgets, taxes, & spending in our city, and if not, what would you change?

            Yes in the small Town I live in and currently serve on the Town Council. I don't know about your city.

7) *Most important of all:  As a constituent, or as an elected representative, what actions have you already personally taken in support of items #1-6 above?

[no answer]

8) Over 1,000 Southern Utahns have signed our online petition so far:  have you?  If not, will you sign it now? Go to:  https://www.southernutahnsfortransparency.com/petition

[petition was signed]

ROCKVILLE COUNCIL

No Rockville candidate has replied to the survey or signed the petition yet

Layney DeLange:  909-499-7000

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Megan Honer-Orton:  435-772-3393

Did not reply to survey once contact was made, and has not signed petition

Robin Smith:  435-817-1124

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Zefferino von Kurnatowski:  225-205-0706

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

SAINT GEORGE COUNCIL

----Sept. 5th Primary and Nov. 21st General Election:  Vote for up to 3 (but if there are only 1 or 2 good candidates, then it’s usually best to only vote for 1 or 2)

--Two St. George candidates completed the survey & petition within two months, before the deadline expired: 

-Paula Smith replied to SUFT’s first round of emails in June, completing her survey on 6/18/23.

-Brad Bennett replied to SUFT’s second round of emails in July, completing his survey on 7/16/23.

--UPDATE: Two additional St. George candidates completed the survey after the deadline, so SUFT is updating the website after the fact, to include all who support hand-counts.  Late responses are included in italics below, since the surveys are key:  they state the candidates’ positions in their own words, they include extra information not on the petition (like budget positions, and actions taken), and they’re a helpful measure of a candidates’ accessibility, responsiveness, and ability to meet a deadline.

-Aros Mackey & Greg Aldred completed surveys on 8/14/23, after the website posting

Aros Mackey:  435-229-4748

Has not yet completed survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across 2 months) and HAS signed petition.

UPDATE: received survey 8/14, after website posting--

1. To eliminate current vulnerabilities to software errors or digital manipulation, do you support a return to hand-counted elections in our city & county? What steps will you take to implement hand-counting in city elections (either during tabulation)

Yes, I support returning to hand counted ballots. I will focus on making a public statement to the county considering they are responsible for the elections this cycle.

2.  In city elections, what steps will you take as a check against ballot-stuffing, which is a separate vulnerability in our elections? (Cast Vote Record Analysis? Actual canvassing of voter rolls? Other?)

I believe citizens' groups should have poll watchers to ensure voter registration with valid ID and that ballots should only be mailed to individuals who are unable to physically go to the polling stations or are deployed military personnel.

3. In city council meetings, will you support a public comment policy that aligns with all our fellow Class 1&2 Counties in Utah, each of which allow open public comment without signup, before any voting, including at least three minutes each for unlimited persons?

The public should have the full right to express their opinions openly. The decision to halt public comments may have been influenced by concerns raised about drag shows targeted at children, which sparked widespread discontent. Most of the comments seamed to centered around this issue, and the city council, lacking a comprehensive response, opted to suspend public comment.

4. Are you in support of a clear city website with one grid that includes links to all city council minutes, recordings, and agendas with detailed links to all items listed so the public is informed about items to be voted on at least one week in advance?

Yes. In fact, the city invests a significant amount of funds in webmasters, which should make the implementation process relatively easy for them.

5. What other steps will you implement to make city government more transparent, accessible, and answerable to the public?

All city business discussions should always be conducted in public, ensuring that every meeting is open to citizens

6.  Do you support current budgets, taxes, & spending in our city, and if not, what would you change?

No; I believe we have the potential for overall improvement. While it may be simple to state this, I strongly feel that we might be approaching an economic downturn and it's crucial for us to proactively prepare for it. The city seems to have an awareness of an impending downturn, yet its spending habits resemble a disregard for the future, rather than making necessary provisions for economic challenges.

7. *Most important of all: As a constituent, or as an elected representative, what actions have you already personally taken in support of items #1-6 above?

I have spoken in city council meetings on public voices, as well as educating friends and family about the vulnerabilities of our election system.

8. Over 1,000 Southern Utahns have signed our online petition so far: have you? If not, will you sign it now? Go to: https://www.southernutahnsfortransparency.com/petition

Yes, I did sign it.

Austin Hodges:  435-222-0332

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Brad Bennett:  435-703-6313   (has signed petition)

1.   To eliminate current vulnerabilities to software errors or digital manipulation, do you support a return to hand-counted elections in our city & county? What steps will you take to implement hand-counting in city elections (either during tabulation or during canvassing)? 

I support hand-counted ballots. Although the county has jurisdiction over elections, I will advocate for this transparent and secure method. Through engaging county officials and raising public awareness, we can foster greater trust in the integrity of our elections.
              [Editors Note:  Per state law, in odd-numbered years, the city has jurisdiction, not the county.  Cities only lose their rights when they give them away in county contracts.]

2.      In city elections, what steps will you take as a check against ballot-stuffing, which is a separate vulnerability in our elections? (Cast Vote Record Analysis? Actual canvassing of voter rolls?  Other?)

Despite the county's control over elections, as a city council member, I can actively contribute to addressing vulnerabilities related to ballot-stuffing. I will advocate for the implementation of robust Cast Vote Record (CVR) analysis to identify irregularities and patterns that may indicate ballot-stuffing. Additionally, I will support the canvassing of voter rolls to ensure their accuracy and legitimacy. Engaging in dialogues with county election officials, raising public awareness, and supporting state-level reforms will collectively strengthen election integrity within our community.
             [Editors Note:  Per state law, in odd-numbered years, the city has control, not the county.  Cities only lose their rights when they give them away in county contracts.]

3.      In city council meetings, will you support a public comment policy that aligns with all our fellow Class 1&2 Counties in Utah, each of which allows open public comment without signup, before voting, including at least three minutes each for unlimited persons?  

Yes, a major aspect of my platform is to enhance public comment and involvement in decision-making.
 
4.      Are you in support of a clear city website with one grid that includes links to all city council minutes, recordings, and agendas with detailed links to all items listed so the public is informed about items to be voted on at least one week in advance? 

Yes, I support a clear city website that includes links to all city council minutes, recordings, and agendas. This will promote transparency and ensure the public has access to information about upcoming votes well in advance.

5.      What other steps will you implement to make city government more transparent, accessible, and answerable to the public? 

 I am fully committed to enhancing transparency, accessibility, and accountability in city government. I will advocate for the creation of unbiased concise video presentations, simplifying complex issues and ensuring equal representation of the pros and cons. I will advocate for the regular conduct of polls and surveys on the city website, enabling improved public education and feedback, thereby empowering citizens to hold elected officials more accountable. Additionally, I plan to personally host listening events to provide direct opportunities for public input, prioritizing the majority voice and respecting their views.

6.      Do you support current budgets, taxes, & spending in our city, and if not, what would you change? 

I am not satisfied with the current budget, tax proposals, and spending in our city. The first step towards improvement should be conducting an impartial third-party audit of our budget and processes to evaluate efficiency and identify areas for optimization. We need to ensure full transparency and demonstrate responsible and efficient use of existing funds before considering any tax increases. For more detailed information about my views on the city budget, I invite you to visit my website at www.ElectBradBennett.com.

7.      *Most important of all:  As a constituent, or as an elected representative, what actions have you already personally taken in support of items #1-6 above?  

As an engaged constituent and dedicated community advocate, I have actively supported various initiatives, solely endorsing candidates for Washington County Clerk who prioritize the practice of hand counting ballots. I have personally spoken with the current county clerk, underscoring the significance of this method, and expressed my deep disappointment when a hand count was not conducted in the Willie Billings race for Utah House of Representatives, despite a slim 7-vote difference. Moreover, as an active member of a local non-profit organization committed to advancing better representation of elected officials, I have actively volunteered my time, diligently pursued GRAMA requests, and effectively utilized multiple platforms such as social media, podcasts, and radio shows to amplify the importance of transparency, public comment opportunities, and other vital public concerns. Additionally, I have proactively participated in city council meetings, lending my voice to address concerns surrounding prudent budget management and proposed tax increases. These concerted actions exemplify my unwavering commitment to upholding transparency, fostering accountability, and genuinely serving the best interests of our valued citizens.

8.      Over 1,000 Southern Utahns have signed our online petition so far:  have you?  If not, will you sign it now?  

Yes, I have signed it.

“Here's the completed City Council Survey. As you can imagine, I receive numerous requests similar to this one, and with my time already significantly occupied by various campaign efforts and duties, I am only able to respond to a limited number of them. However, I want to emphasize that I genuinely recognize the significance of this particular issue, and I have made it a priority to respond to your group's questions. I sincerely appreciate the vital work you are doing and I commend you on your efforts. Keep up the good work! Regards, Brad Bennett, St. George City Council Candidate”

Dannielle Larkin, incumbent:  435-619-9971

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Fabian Ortiz:  435-668-6942

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Greg Aldred:  435-632-2807

Has not signed petition, nor publicly answered all 8 survey questions.  Sent only this--

“I'm all about transparent elections and in person voting. And we're watching the city of hurricane to see how their efforts work out. I'll never silence the people we don't rule. Thanks for your questions.  If you need to discuss anymore in detail, you can call me  435-632-2807”

UPDATE: received survey & petition on 8/14, after website posting--

1) To eliminate current vulnerabilities to software errors or digital manipulation, do you support a return to hand-counted elections in our city & county?  What steps will you take to implement hand-counting in city elections (either during tabulation, or during canvassing)?

            I support a return to hand counting and adding more poll watchers

2) In city elections, what steps will you take as a check against ballot-stuffing, which is a separate vulnerability in our elections? (Cast Vote Record Analysis? Actual canvassing of voter rolls?  Other?)

            Actual canvassing of voters rolls!

3) In city council meetings, will you support a public comment policy that aligns with all our fellow Class 1&2 Counties in Utah, each of which allow open public comment without signup, before any voting, including at least three minutes each for unlimited persons?

            Absolutely

4) Are you in support of a clear city website with one grid that includes links to all city council minutes, recordings, and agendas with detailed links to all items listed so the public is informed about items to be voted on at least one week in advance?

            yes

5) What other steps will you implement to make city government more transparent, accessible, and answerable to the public?

            I'd like to include a crime report to inform our citizens where problems exist.

6) Do you support current budgets, taxes, & spending in our city, and if not, what would you change?

            I would support an independent audit.

7) *Most important of all:  As a constituent, or as an elected representative, what actions have you already personally taken in support of items #1-6 above?

            In my last election I made recommendations to protect our power grid.  I did help canvas some voters.

8) Over 1,000 Southern Utahns have signed our online petition so far:  have you?  If not, will you sign it now? Go to:  https://www.southernutahnsfortransparency.com/petition

            Yes I did sign. Please let me know if it did not go through.

Gregg McArthur, incumbent:  801-520-5566

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Jimmie Hughes, incumbent:  435-772-6208

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months). Mailbox full.

Katheryne Knight:  435-817-2019

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Kimball Willard: 435-652-0549    (has not signed petition)

Thank you for allowing me extra time to respond to your request. Last week was extremely hectic for me.

1) To eliminate current vulnerabilities to software errors or digital manipulation, do you support a return to hand-counted elections in our city & county?  What steps will you take to implement hand-counting in city elections (either during tabulation, or during canvassing)?

I do support hand recounts. I think Hurricane's request to the County and Lieutenant Governor's office will be very telling as to what will be allowed from a legal standpoint. I find the use of the tabulating machines to be a much smaller concern (especially with the new machine that will allow separation of ballots to the precinct level, so hand recounts can validate the tabulating machines) than the universal mail in ballots. How much effect does hand recounts have if additional ballots are introduced to the system? Since changes are made incrementally in this political world, I believe the energy at this point should be focused on the Utah Legislature moving us back to in person voting, with valid ID required, with absentee balloting where appropriate (still requiring a voter to make an effort with an ID before hand).

[Editor’s Note: the question was about hand COUNTS, not hand RE-COUNTS]

2) In city elections, what steps will you take as a check against ballot-stuffing, which is a separate vulnerability in our elections? (Cast Vote Record Analysis? Actual canvassing of voter rolls?  Other?)

As the process currently stands, there is little that I would be able to do as a city council member. Again, I look to see what Washington County and the Utah Lieutenant Governor's office respond to Hurricane's City's response to get a better understanding what is allowed under the current law. I've had in-depth conversations with County Clerk's office, and have discussed the security measures in place for the upcoming elections (including the upgraded camera system on all ballot drop off locations, as required by State law). As for canvasing, while the city Mayors and City Councils are on the canvasing committees for their jurisdictions, the actual canvasing are run by the county, per state law. Again, I see the mail in voting system to be the biggest security risk in our voting process, and would continue to discuss with out County Legislature members (as well as like minded Legislatures from across the state) to change the law to move us back to in person balloting with absentee balloting where appropriate (still requiring a voter to make an effort with an ID before hand).

[Editor’s Note:  Per state law, in odd-numbered years, canvassing is run by the city, not the county]

3) In city council meetings, will you support a public comment policy that aligns with all our fellow Class 1&2 Counties in Utah, each of which allow open public comment without signup, before any voting, including at least three minutes each for unlimited persons?

            Absolutely. The citizens have a right to be heard.

4) Are you in support of a clear city website with one grid that includes links to all city council minutes, recordings, and agendas with detailed links to all items listed so the public is informed about items to be voted on at least one week in advance?

           I absolutely am in support of giving greater clarity to the St. George City website on finding official records. I've become pretty good at locating the agendas (very easy to find under the notices tab), but have notices the minutes lookup is not working. I would push to have this fixed immediately. I would also push to have links added to the agendas of pertinent information an all agenda items. As there are no city codes addressing, I would push on the Mayor (who created the Agenda's) to have all agenda's available one week prior to meetings, with the understanding that emergency items may be added within that week for unexpected items. Since the council has no actual authority in this area, I would encourage the Mayor nonetheless.

5) What other steps will you implement to make city government more transparent, accessible, and answerable to the public?

Due to actions taken by our current city administration, whether intentional or by happenstance, an aura of "us vs them" has emanated from several departments. I think it's vital to begin discussions with each department, to make sure the correct mentality of working together with the citizens, not against exists, and to root out those that cause problems, rather than fix problems.

6) Do you support current budgets, taxes, & spending in our city, and if not, what would you change?

            I do not support the current city budget. Its growth has outpaced the growth of the community since at least 2018. We have been told that all city organizations that operate under the Enterprise Funds operate as businesses. It's not the role of government to be in business. I would require to have each "business" in the enterprise fund to create a profit/loss statement (as each private business should do each year), so evaluations could be made as to efficiencies and possible elimination of each unit. I would begin discussions of each unit within the city to find and eliminate wasted funds. I would also attempt (working with the rest of the council) to create a separate rainy day fund that would require City Council approval for use. My vision would have .5% of the tax revenue received each year to be put into this fund. At the end of each fiscal year, if the fund exceeds 10% of the tax revenue, the overage would be moved back to the General Fund. This way, the city would be prepared for true emergencies (beyond the 60 - 90 days of funds the city currently considers it's "rainy day funds").

7) *Most important of all:  As a constituent, or as an elected representative, what actions have you already personally taken in support of items #1-6 above?

I spoke to the City Council last year at the Tax Hearings, to stop the unneeded tax increase requested by the Mayor and City Manager. I spoke again at both public hearings in June about the proposed budget for the next fiscal year, calling the obvious waste and unsupportable budget growth.

8) Over 1,000 Southern Utahns have signed our online petition so far:  have you?  If not, will you sign it now? Go to:  https://www.southernutahnsfortransparency.com/petition

I will not sign the petition. The petition as currently constructed is actually 4 petitions. To me, this is akin to signing an omnibus funding bill. To get my signature, I would require 4 separate petitions. 

[Editor’s note:  This is incorrect—PDF copies of the petition are available online to print, and any item can be crossed out or marked as a single stand-alone item]

Marilyn Rigby:  801-608-6049

Has not signed petition, nor publicly answered the full survey.  Sent only this--

“I am running for City Council because it is a non partisan position and I think  I can make sure that  everyone is represented. I believe the doors should always be open so the citizens of St. George will know we are transparent. We are elected to serve with a team to represent St. George .and it’s Citizens.  We can not just represent a few of the biggest business owners.  I believe in you the people that I hope will elect me. I hear your voice.  I have lived in big cities including La county , SanDiego county and Fresno county . I have lived in SLC and West Jordan.  I know what can happen to a city if it’s Citizens are not represented. I am ready to do this job for you. I am caring and strong . I have a web site. MarilynRigby. Com. I want you to know that if We  thought our election was being manipulated by machine or otherwise , we would have a recount. The votes would be counted by hand if we thought the machine were not functioning .I don’t think we are having a problem at all like that. I really like mail in votes. They have to be on time if possible, IT WOULd  BE NEARLY IMPOSSIBLE TO CHEAT WITH  the  MACHINES. I Jerry meandering is a way of cheating  and that concerns me. . I don’t like We have to be able to trust our leaders . I will have an open door policy. You can call me anytime your concerned. I will represent everyone and will listen to you !  Vote Rigby for City Council.”

Matthew Heaton:  801-413-3366

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Paula Smith: 435-414-0113     (has signed the petition)

1.      To eliminate current vulnerabilities to software errors or digital manipulation, do you support a return to hand-counted elections in our city & county?  What steps will you take to implement hand-counting in city elections (either during tabulation, or during canvassing)? 

In-person, paper ballot voting (non-electronic) is the most secure and reliable way to ensure fair and accurate election results. Although machines can be used for counting, complete hand-counting verification must always be part of the process to guarantee that every vote is counted correctly. The hand-count step is essential to maintain the integrity of the election, which should be a priority. 

2.      In city elections, what steps will you take as a check against ballot-stuffing, which is a separate vulnerability in our elections? (Cast Vote Record Analysis? Actual canvassing of voter rolls?  Other?)

 What sets me apart from others is that I ask questions. I don't listen to instructions and then mindlessly follow the script. If I notice something that needs to be corrected or skewing results, I'd speak up to get answers or seek a change to the system. I welcome suggestions and listen to input; transparency should be a priority.  

3.      In city council meetings, will you support a public comment policy that aligns with all our fellow Class 1&2 Counties in Utah, each of which allow open public comment without signup, before any voting, including at least three minutes each for unlimited persons?

I support public comment. I'd take it a step further, as it's important to allow comments from a broader range of residents, not just those who reside in St George. Many neighboring residents have close connections to St George through their businesses, shopping, dining, recreation, and more. It's fair to allow them to express their opinions and concerns. I disagree with the rule of not discussing anything on the agenda; this would be the ideal time to address concerns.

 4.      Are you in support of a clear city website with one grid that includes links to all city council minutes, recordings, and agendas with detailed links to all items listed so the public is informed about items to be voted on at least one week in advance? 

YES, YES, YES! I've gone before the Council on this very topic. Transparency is my platform, and we need more of it. Washington City offers its council voting records online, showing how each council member voted for each agenda item. St George should be doing this too. The city is revamping its website, and I suggested incorporating the links for the work meetings, minutes, etc... Additionally, there should be a better recording system--navigating the current system is challenging.

 5.      What other steps will you implement to make city government more transparent, accessible, and answerable to the public? 

 I'd like to see more communications, updates after meetings, Council voting records, and ONE site to access city meetings, with organized links by each date/event in a searchable format. I'd like to have the budget show more detail, for instance, the $188,000 "revenue" on the golf course administration--this should be reflected in a separate account with a notation of where this was transferred from (it was CARES act money). A lot of money is transferred within the budget; I'd like to see it better displayed on those specific line items with notations showing the transfers.  

 6.      Do you support current budgets, taxes, & spending in our city, and if not, what would you change?

Our budget has exploded. $170 million added in 4 years, having only 10k added people, we have a spending problem. I'm eager to review the upcoming study examining different departments to determine if the city-run or private-sector options would result in savings. This study includes (if I'm not mistaken) fleet and golf (among other departments). It could also help identify potential areas where we can make cuts and reduce spending.

7.      *Most important of all:  As a constituent, or as an elected representative, what actions have you already personally taken in support of items #1-6 above? 

            After conducting a comprehensive review of the current and past budget, I have taken the initiative to ask numerous questions and presented concerning data for further inspection directly to the Council (this data was utilized and mentioned within public meetings). My involvement in the fight against last year's added property tax has given me a solid understanding of prioritizing public safety over added tax strategy. I have reached out to many state leaders encouraging a collaboration of ideas for property tax changes.  I encourage voters to review my website and contact me directly to ask questions.www.PaulaSmithCityCouncil.com Additionally, I have attended several events over the past year, and I've gained clarity and perspective on many issues. #IknowBruceFunk 

8.      Over 1,000 Southern Utahns have signed our online petition so far:  have you?  If not, will you sign it now? Go to:  https://www.southernutahnsfortransparency.com/petition

I think that we did at one of the events. My husband and I both. We handed out several pages to friends and neighbors and attended several events.  [has signed petition]

Steve Kemp: 435-313-7007

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Steven Jennings: 435-632-2910

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Wendy Bulkley: 435-680-8366

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

--Withdrawn from race:  Kent Perkins

SANTA CLARA COUNCIL

No Santa Clara candidate has replied to the survey or signed the petition yet

David Pond:  801-560-8507

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Jarett Waite:  435-862-1811

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Leina Mathis:  435-632-5358

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Withdrawn from race:  Janene Burton

SPRINGDALE COUNCIL

--On Nov. 21st General Election, vote for up to 2.

--No Springdale candidate has replied to the survey or signed the petition yet

Kyla Topham:  918-384-9121

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Noel Benson:  980-322-1432

He texted STOP to caller:  Did not reply to survey once contact was made, and has not signed petition

Pat Campbell:  503-793-6536

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

TOQUERVILLE COUNCIL: 2 YR TERM

--On Nov. 21st General Election, vote for 1.

--No Toquerville candidate has replied to the survey or signed the petition yet

Chuck Williams:  703-624-6995

Hung up on caller:  Did not reply to survey once contact was made, and has not signed petition

Wayne Olsen:  435-680-4507

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

TOQUERVILLE COUNCIL: 4 YR TERM

--On Nov. 21st General Election, vote for 1.

--No Toquerville candidate has replied to the survey or signed the petition yet

Joey Campbell: 435-632-2211

Did not reply to survey once contact was made, and has not signed petition

Todd Sands:  805-796-4765

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

TOQUERVILLE MAYOR

--One mayoral candidate has filed for Nov. 21st General Election:

Justin Sip:  435-668-0848

Has not completed petition or survey—is running unopposed.

VIRGIN COUNCIL

--Sept. 5th Primary and Nov. 21st General Election:  Vote for up to 2 (but if there are only 1 or 2 good candidates, then it’s usually best to only vote for 1 or 2)

--One Virgin candidate has signed the petition so far:  Cameron Spendlove

April McKeon:  435-691-2827   (has not signed petition)

1) To eliminate current vulnerabilities to software errors or digital manipulation, do you support a return to hand-counted elections in our city & county?  What steps will you take to implement hand-counting in city elections (either during tabulation, or during canvassing)?

I do believe in the integrity of our election process. I am not against hand counting of the votes. That is the way it has been done in Virgin. We too have a divided city and took steps in the last election to ensure transparency in our vote counting. We made certain that there were volunteers accompanying the person collecting the ballots and made certain that they were properly handled after collection.

2) In city elections, what steps will you take as a check against ballot-stuffing, which is a separate vulnerability in our elections? (Cast Vote Record Analysis? Actual canvassing of voter rolls?  Other?)

I do not think ballot stuffing is an actual problem

[Editor’s Note:  the question was about our vulnerability to ballot-stuffing]

3) In city council meetings, will you support a public comment policy that aligns with all our fellow Class 1&2 Counties in Utah, each of which allow open public comment without signup, before any voting, including at least three minutes each for unlimited persons?

Yes, absolutely the public should have the opportunity to comment.

4) Are you in support of a clear city website with one grid that includes links to all city council minutes, recordings, and agendas with detailed links to all items listed so the public is informed about items to be voted on at least one week in advance?

Yes, absolutely.

5) What other steps will you implement to make city government more transparent, accessible, and answerable to the public?

Access to public records without the need for a GAMMA request for every item. Absolute transparency in public fund use. All town business should be conducted on town/ city property. The ability for citizens to have the email or phone contact information of all public officials. No conflicts of interest of public officials should be allowed. Ensure the public has access to meetings online.

6) Do you support current budgets, taxes, & spending in our city, and if not, what would you change?

I am not familiar enough with the town budget to comment. I would like to see a breakdown of the amount of money generated by short term rental tax.

7) *Most important of all:  As a constituent, or as an elected representative, what actions have you already personally taken in support of items #1-6 above?

I attend many public meetings in person or by online access. I also am on many committees within the town to help reduce the workload of the elected officials. I am not currently an elected official.

8) Over 1,000 Southern Utahns have signed our online petition so far:  have you?  If not, will you sign it now? Go to:  https://www.southernutahnsfortransparency.com/petition

[has not signed petition yet]

Cameron Spendlove:  435-773-1153

Has not replied to survey (after 2 emails, text, and 1 phone call) and HAS signed petition

Gene Garate:  435-339-7002

Did not reply to survey once contact was made, and has not signed petition

Marci Holm:  435-467-5738

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Valerie Wenz:  435-773-5994

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

--Withdrawn from race:  Kent Peterson

WASHINGTON CITY COUNCIL

--On November 21st, vote for up to 3 (but if there are only 1 or 2 good candidates, then it’s usually best to only vote for 1 or 2)

--No Washington City candidate has signed the petition yet

Ben Martinsen, 435-229-1198   (has not signed petition)

1) To eliminate current vulnerabilities to software errors or digital manipulation, do you support a return to hand-counted elections in our city & county?  What steps will you take to implement hand-counting in city elections (either during tabulation, or during canvassing)?

            This was passed this year at the state level HB2001 (utah.gov) and does not allow (from my understanding) for a hand count at a city level because it is to be handled at the county level for 2023. Any election issues are to be taken up with the Lt Governor in Utah. This process can definitely be challenged and should always be challenged to make sure it is done as efficiently, as effectively, and as safeguarded as possible.  I am always open to ideas and suggestions, and working through the proper channels, on how we can improve upon the security of all of our elections.

2) In city elections, what steps will you take as a check against ballot-stuffing, which is a separate vulnerability in our elections? (Cast Vote Record Analysis? Actual canvassing of voter rolls?  Other?)

            Since I am currently on City Council and canvassing involves city council members and cannot be delegated or hired out (as explained to me and I could be misinformed or wrong in my understanding of this), I will trust our city recorder and her team to properly vet the process.  If truly able to be delegated, it is worth looking into it to verify the results in a proper fashion.  We are working with the county to inspect the ballots during the canvassing period this year and they will make sure it is all inline and compliant.

3) In city council meetings, will you support a public comment policy that aligns with all our fellow Class 1&2 Counties in Utah, each of which allow open public comment without signup, before any voting, including at least three minutes each for unlimited persons?

            I am slowly working on getting these back to the public meetings. I have pushed and we have now started our neighborhood gatherings on the fifth Wednesday of the month. I am always accessible via email, phone call, sometimes a little delayed with this one due to work meetings, text, social media, and almost any other channel of communication. I am not sure how well a carrier pigeon would find me but, if needed, we could figure it out.

4) Are you in support of a clear city website with one grid that includes links to all city council minutes, recordings, and agendas with detailed links to all items listed so the public is informed about items to be voted on at least one week in advance?

            Washington City already has something like this, and I am always open to listening to all ideas and ways to make the site and public information more accessible. I was initially the one (while on planning commission) to ask for the packet items to be published for public access, so everyone could see them before the meeting. We should always work towards making the website more clear so that all public meeting information is as easy to find as possible.  I am always open to any and all suggestions to make the information as accessible and simple as possible.

5) What other steps will you implement to make city government more transparent, accessible, and answerable to the public?

            Washington City is pretty transparent, but can always be better. We never want to be stagnant in what we do for all residents. I continue to work on more public comment and have asked for this a few times and will continue to ask for this to happen.  Much like the previous question about the city website, I am always available to listen and to see how we can make our city government more transparent, accessible, and answerable to the public. I am available, even when traveling for work, on my phone, via text, via email, via social media, almost any channel you can think of, I can be reached and will respond.

6) Do you support current budgets, taxes, & spending in our city, and if not, what would you change?

            For Washington City, there are certainly some items that can be looked at a little more closely. For the most part, we did a decent job and we, as a council, are always looking at the investments, building permits, incoming sales tax, etc.… and have our financial director constantly looking at the budget to make sure we stay balanced and we do not go over budget… ever.  We can ALWAYS  do better and are regularly looking at the budget to make sure we stay within budget and the money is spent where it should be. I currently voted against adding a sales tax increase to the ballot this year, and we will have to work with what we have… Just like we do in a family! As the other questions, I am always open to any and all suggestions to make the information as accessible and simple as possible.

7) *Most important of all:  As a constituent, or as an elected representative, what actions have you already personally taken in support of items #1-6 above?

            Detailed in the actual answer to the question. No need to bloviate here. I also think that being accessible, wanting to challenge the process to make our local government even better, and listening to, and visiting with residents, through any form of communication, is something that not a lot of elected officials do. Helping the residents know that their voice is heard even if the outcome is not what was expected, or preferred is a major part of how I offer to serve.

8) Over 1,000 Southern Utahns have signed our online petition so far:  have you?  If not, will you sign it now? Go to:  https://www.southernutahnsfortransparency.com/petition

            I would like to know the plan on this and where you plan on presenting the petition and signatures since the state is the one to control all of the election protocols and how those are handled?  “I am not fully onboard with the hand count”

            [has not signed petition]

Craig Coats:  435-632-3343

Did not reply to survey once contact was made, and has not signed petition 

Ed Tracey: 916-770-9665

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Kurt Ivie: 435-632-4950

Has not completed petition or survey (after 2 emails, text, & 1 phone call, across two months)

Troy Belliston: 435-229-3785   (has not signed petition)

1.      To eliminate current vulnerabilities to software errors or digital manipulation, do you support a return to hand-counted elections in our city & county?  What steps will you take to implement hand-counting in city elections (either during tabulation, or during canvassing)? 

 I support a robust accounting, auditing and certification process of all of our election systems.  As a young servicemember stationed in Europe I started using paper vote by mail in the early 90’s and have voted by mail ever since.  In Utah our vote by mail ballot is able to be tracked from mailing to destination and any eligible voter can follow their vote.  I recognize that any ballot system needs to be scrutinized for the safety and security of our individual votes and I support continued and regular reviews of our ballot integrity protocols.

[Editor’s Note:  the question was about hand-counts]

2.      In city elections, what steps will you take as a check against ballot-stuffing, which is a separate vulnerability in our elections? (Cast Vote Record Analysis? Actual canvassing of voter rolls?  Other?)  

I am a big supporter of serial numbered ballots, Voter ID requirements, and regular reviews of the voter rolls to weed out ballot recipients that may no longer live here or are eligible to receive a ballot.

3.      In city council meetings, will you support a public comment policy that aligns with all our fellow Class 1&2 Counties in Utah, each of which allow open public comment without signup, before any voting, including at least three minutes each for unlimited persons?  

More public involvement rather than less public involvement is preferred.  Which is why I was surprised and disappointed when the current Washington City Council unanimously voted to eliminate public hearings for both General Plan changes and Zone changes.  (See Council 10/12/22 minutes and agenda items)  I think that it is essential that public input is welcomed and encouraged and not silenced.  Our constituents should be able to look our elected leaders eye to eye and voice their concerns in a public hearing vs letting our elected leaders view the constituents comments over YouTube.

4.      Are you in support of a clear city website with one grid that includes links to all city council minutes, recordings, and agendas with detailed links to all items listed so the public is informed about items to be voted on at least one week in advance?  

Absolutely!  I believe that Washington City has done a good job of hosting the information online since 2018.  

5.      What other steps will you implement to make city government more transparent, accessible, and answerable to the public?  

Transparency in government is paramount to our democracy.  I support any effort or action that will illuminate the discussions.

6.      Do you support current budgets, taxes, & spending in our city, and if not, what would you change?  

No.  I do not support taking out a $10m General Fund Sales Tax bond for a “Want” (See Council 3/9/22 minutes and agenda items), which would be a city owned $15m skate park, vs a “Need”, which is currently 2 badly needed fire stations (See Council 6/14/23 minutes and agenda items) and other public safety infrastructure.  Government has one purpose above all else and that is the safety of our community.  Everything else is simply frosting.  A “Need” should never be placed behind a “Want” and by taking out a General Fund Sales Tax bond for a skate park we just put that park in a position that it will be paid for before the first officer heads out on his shift, or the first fireman responds to his first call of the day.  Our public safety should never have to compete for funds against a skate park and I would redeploy those bonded dollars towards the construction of badly needed public safety infrastructure. Parks should instead be funded through the capital facilities plan so that they are impact fee eligible.

7.      *Most important of all:  As a constituent, or as an elected representative, what actions have you already personally taken in support of items #1-6 above?  

It used to be that Planning Commission and City Council agenda items were available for review in the city offices.  Just after being elected to the Washington City Council in 2016,  I pushed for all agenda items, staff reports, and project submittals to be hosted on the city website.  Since 2018 in Washington City those agenda items have been hosted online and are available for public review prior to public meetings or anytime thereafter.  I support continued efforts to make public documents and council votes even more accessible for review.

8) Over 1,000 Southern Utahns have signed our online petition so far:  have you?  If not, will you sign it now? Go to:  https://www.southernutahnsfortransparency.com/petition

[has not signed petition]

Withdrawn from race:  Doug Scheel